Practical guide
Abnormally low tenders and the rejection of all tenders
A tender whose value is abnormally low given the subject matter of the contract must be explained before the contracting authority can accept it. This guide sets out when the authority must ask for an explanation, what the explanation may rely on, when the tender must or may be rejected, and when the authority may reject all tenders.
Reviewed by Mara Ribeiro Duarte, Head of Public Sector at Closer · 20 November 2026
Legal basis§ 115(1) · § 115(1¹) · § 115(2) · § 115(2¹) · § 115(7) · § 115(7) cl 1 · § 115(7) cl 2 · § 115(7) cl 3 · § 115(7) cl 4 · § 115(7) cl 5 · § 115(8) · § 115(9) · § 115(10) · § 125(5) · § 52(2) · § 52(3) · § 114(1) · § 117(1) · § 117(4) · § 116(1) cl 1 · § 116(1) cl 2 · § 116(2) cl 1 · § 116(2) cl 2 · § 73(3) cl 2 · § 73(3) cl 3 · § 47(1) cl 5 · § 47(1) cl 6 · § 47(4) cl 2 · official text
What the rule is for
A very low price may mean that the tenderer has found a cheaper way to perform the contract, or that it cannot perform it on the terms it offers. The Act does not forbid low tenders. It requires the contracting authority to ask for an explanation where it finds the value of a tender (pakkumuse maksumus) unreasonably low given the subject matter of the contract, and to reject the tender only where the explanation does not remove that finding (§ 115(1), § 115(8)).
The Estonian term is põhjendamatult madala maksumusega pakkumus. The official English translation uses both "unreasonably low" and "abnormally low" for it; this guide uses "abnormally low".
When the authority must ask for an explanation
- General rule. Where the authority finds that the value of a tender is unreasonably low given the subject matter of the contract, it must require the tenderer to explain it, in a form reproducible in writing. The tenderer must submit the explanation, in the same form, within five working days of receiving the request (§ 115(1)).
- No general numeric test. Apart from the works rule below, the Act sets no percentage or other figure that makes a tender abnormally low. Whether a value is unreasonably low is for the authority to assess against the subject matter of the contract (§ 115(1)).
- Works contracts of at least 500 000 euros. For a public works contract with an estimated value of at least 500 000 euros, the authority must ask for the explanation from the tenderer whose tender it intends to declare successful where at least three tenders were submitted and that tender is at least 10 per cent lower than the next tender or at least 20 per cent lower than the average value of the tenders submitted (§ 115(2)).
- Other percentages. The procurement documents may set other percentages for that works rule: between 5 and 15 per cent compared with the next tender and between 10 and 30 per cent compared with the average. Where they set none, the 10 and 20 per cent figures apply (§ 115(2¹)).
- Concessions. For a concession contract the authority is not required to ask for the explanation, unless the procurement documents provide otherwise (§ 115(1¹)).
- Simple procedure. In the simple procedure the authority applies § 115 unless the procurement documents provide otherwise, and for a works contract with an estimated value of at least 500 000 euros it follows § 115 in any case (§ 125(5)).
The works rule does not say that a tender meeting the percentages is abnormally low. It obliges the authority to ask; the authority then assesses the explanation under § 115(8) like any other.
What the explanation may cover
The Act lists, as examples ("above all"), what may justify a low value (§ 115(7)):
- the economics of the manufacturing process, of the services provided or of the construction method (§ 115(7) cl 1);
- the technical solutions chosen by the tenderer or exceptionally favourable conditions available to it for performing the contract (§ 115(7) cl 2);
- the uniqueness (ainulaadsus; "originality" in the official translation) of the supplies, services or works (§ 115(7) cl 3);
- the environmental, social and labour law provisions in force at the place of performance that the tenderer or its subcontractor must comply with (§ 115(7) cl 4);
- the possibility of the tenderer obtaining state aid (§ 115(7) cl 5).
The list is not closed, so the tenderer may rely on other circumstances. As practical advice, a request that names the items of the tender that look low, and asks for evidence and not only assertions, makes the explanation easier to verify and the later decision easier to reason.
Assessing the explanation and rejecting the tender
- Verification. The authority verifies the explanation and assesses the evidence offered, consulting the tenderer where needed (§ 115(8)).
- Rejection. Where the authority still finds the value unreasonably low, or the tenderer does not provide the required explanation, the authority rejects the tender by a reasoned written decision (§ 115(8)).
- Environmental, social and labour law. The authority must reject the tender where it establishes that the abnormally low value is caused by disregard of the environmental, social or labour law provisions in force at the place of performance (§ 115(9)).
- State aid. Where the value is abnormally low because the tenderer has obtained state aid, the authority may reject the tender only after the tenderer has failed to prove, within a reasonable time limit set by the authority, that the aid was compatible with the law. If it rejects the tender on that ground and the estimated value of the contract equals or exceeds the international threshold, it informs the European Commission through the Ministry of Finance (§ 115(10)).
- Notice. A decision rejecting a tender is notified to the economic operators taking part in the procurement (§ 47(1) cl 5), with the reasons for the rejection given to the tenderer concerned (§ 47(4) cl 2).
Where it fits in the evaluation
In the ordinary order the authority checks exclusion grounds and qualification, then the conformity of the tenders of the selected tenderers, and then evaluates the suitable tenders (§ 52(2)); in the reverse procedure conformity and evaluation come first (§ 52(3)). Conformity ends in a reasoned decision declaring tenders suitable or rejecting them (§ 114(1)), and only suitable tenders are evaluated against the award criteria (§ 117(1)).
The Act does not name a separate step for § 115. The works rule refers to the tender the authority intends to declare successful (§ 115(2)), which suggests that the authority will often know the ranking before it asks. Our reading is that the explanation should in any case be obtained and assessed before a tender is declared successful, since a rejected tender cannot win. How tenders are scored is in the guide on award criteria.
The issue can also arise after the award decision. The authority may decide not to conclude the contract with the successful tenderer where it establishes that the tenderer has not taken account of the environmental, social and labour law provisions in force at the place of performance. It then rejects the successful tender by a written decision, evaluates the remaining tenders again and declares successful the most economically advantageous of the suitable tenders (§ 117(4)).
Rejecting all tenders
Rejecting the lowest tender often leaves only tenders above the budget. The authority may make a reasoned written decision to reject all tenders where:
- the values of all tenders, or of all suitable tenders, exceed the estimated value of the contract (§ 116(1) cl 1); or
- the procurement documents provided for rejecting all tenders on objective and non-discriminatory grounds and such a ground exists (§ 116(1) cl 2).
Where the procurement is divided into lots within a single procedure, the authority may reject all tenders for a lot where one of those grounds exists for it (§ 116(2) cl 1), and for lots that would be impractical to award, or would not serve the purpose of the procurement, without a lot for which the procedure has ended on one of the grounds in clauses 2–7 of § 73(3) (§ 116(2) cl 2).
The procedure ends when all tenders have been rejected because none was suitable or all were abnormally low (§ 73(3) cl 2), or on the grounds of § 116 (§ 73(3) cl 3). The decision rejecting all tenders is notified to the participants (§ 47(1) cl 6).
The procedure as a whole is in the guide on the open procedure and the guide on the simple procedure, related questions in the FAQ on selection, exclusion and award, and how to contest a rejection in the guide on contestation. This guide repeats the Act and does not cover case law on when a tender is abnormally low.
Related pages
Previous guide
Award criteria, life-cycle costing and the evaluation of tenders
Next guide
Modifying a public contract during its term
Want your procurement documents checked before publication? We will show you how Procurelex Verifika does it.
Request a demoGeneral information on the Public Procurement Act in force. Not legal advice.