Skip to content

Practical guide

Award criteria, life-cycle costing and the evaluation of tenders

How the contracting authority sets the award criteria (pakkumuste hindamise kriteeriumid) for the most economically advantageous tender, weights them and calculates life-cycle costs, and how it then checks conformity, evaluates the tenders, declares the successful tender and assesses variants.

Updated 19 November 2026

Reviewed by Mara Ribeiro Duarte, Head of Public Sector at Closer · 20 November 2026

Legal basis§ 85(1) · § 85(2) · § 85(3) · § 85(4) · § 85(5) · § 85(6) · § 85(7) · § 85(8) cl 1 · § 85(8) cl 2 · § 85(8) cl 3 · § 85(9) · § 85(10) · § 101(1) cl 6 · § 77(4) cl 2 · § 77(4) cl 3 · § 4 cl 17 · § 88(5) · § 89(2) · § 86(1) · § 86(2) cl 1 · § 86(2) cl 2 · § 86(3) · § 86(4) · § 114(1) · § 114(1¹) · § 114(2) · § 114(8) · § 117(1) · § 117(1¹) · § 117(2) · § 117(3) · § 117(4) · § 118(1) · § 118(2) · § 118(3) · § 119(1) · § 119(2) · § 47(1) · § 47(1) cl 10 · § 47(4) cl 3 · § 47(5) · § 125(2) · § 125(5) · § 185(2) cl 1 · § 185(2) cl 7 · official text

What the award criteria are for

The award criteria decide which of the conforming tenders wins. The contracting authority sets them in the procurement documents to identify the most economically advantageous tender (majanduslikult soodsaim pakkumus). They must be related to the subject matter of the public contract and ensure actual competition (§ 85(1)). The procurement documents contain the award criteria in accordance with §§ 85 and 86 (§ 77(4) cl 2; see also § 4 cl 17).

The award criteria are kept apart from the selection criteria. A selection criterion set under §§ 99–101 may not be used as an award criterion (§ 85(1)). There is one exception: the educational and professional qualifications of the tenderer or candidate, of its managers or of the persons responsible for providing the services or managing the works (§ 101(1) cl 6) may be an award criterion, where they show the authority the economic advantageousness of the tender and are not used for selection (§ 85(1)).

A criterion is still linked to the subject matter where it takes account of processes related to the production of the supplies, the provision of the services or the execution of the works, or their marketing, or of activities and costs at other stages of the life cycle, even where these are not an essential element of the subject matter (§ 85(2)).

Price, cost and quality

When identifying the most economically advantageous tender, the authority takes into account in particular the best price-quality ratio, which includes qualitative, ecofriendliness or social criteria, and the tender price or cost, including costs likely to be incurred in performing the contract and life-cycle costs under § 86 (§ 85(3)). The Act then sets out the variations:

  • Price or cost alone. Allowed only where the economic advantageousness of the tender depends for the authority solely on price or cost, and all other terms of the prospective contract, including the criteria related to the subject matter, are exhaustively determined in the procurement documents (§ 85(4)). The quality the authority needs must then be fixed in the documents, for example in the technical specifications.
  • Quality alone, at a fixed price. The authority may fix the price or cost of the contract in the procurement documents and evaluate the tenders solely on qualitative, ecofriendliness or social criteria (§ 85(7)).
  • Innovation partnership and competitive dialogue. Only the best price-quality ratio may be used (§ 85(5)).
  • Software solutions. When buying software solutions, the authority takes into account life-cycle costs under § 86 in addition to the price, or states in the procurement documents why it does not (§ 85(6)).

The qualitative, ecofriendliness or social criteria may be, above all:

  • quality, including technical merit, aesthetic, functional, environmental, social and innovative characteristics, accessibility and trading conditions (§ 85(8) cl 1);
  • the specific and proven organisation, qualification or experience of the persons directly involved in performing the contract, where the quality of performance directly depends on it (§ 85(8) cl 2);
  • after-sales service and technical assistance, and delivery and installation terms (§ 85(8) cl 3).

The authority may also require a specific label as an award criterion, under the conditions of § 89(2), and a test report or certificate from a conformity assessment body as proof that a tender meets the award criteria (§ 88(5)).

Weighting

The authority specifies in the procurement documents the relative weighting of each award criterion; a weighting may be expressed as a maximum range (§ 85(9)). Where weighting is not possible for objective reasons described in the procurement documents, the authority lists the criteria in decreasing order of importance (§ 85(10)).

The Act does not prescribe a scoring formula. As a matter of practice, it helps to state in the documents how each criterion will be scored and how points will be converted, so that tenderers know in advance how their tenders will be compared and the evaluation can be checked afterwards.

Life-cycle costing

The life cycle (olelusring) means all consecutive or interlinked stages of the supplies, services or works, including research and development, production, trading and its conditions, transport, use and maintenance, from raw material acquisition or generation of resources to disposal and the end of service or use (§ 86(1)).

When calculating life-cycle costs, the authority takes into account, in part or in full:

  • costs borne by the authority or third parties during the performance of the contract for the acquisition, use and maintenance of the subject matter, and end-of-life costs (§ 86(2) cl 1);
  • costs imputed to environmental externalities that can be determined and measured in money (§ 86(2) cl 2).

The authority describes in the procurement documents the method it uses and the documents the tenderer must submit to determine the costs (§ 86(3)). The method for environmental externalities must be publicly available and based on verifiable, non-discriminatory criteria that do not restrict competition; the data and documents required must be obtainable with reasonable effort by a normally diligent tenderer (§ 86(4)).

Conformity before evaluation

Only conforming tenders are evaluated. The authority checks the tenders against the terms of the procurement documents and makes a reasoned written decision to declare them suitable or to reject them; a rejected tenderer takes no further part in the procedure (§ 114(1)). It rejects a tender that does not meet those terms, where the tenderer does not provide the required clarifications in time, or where the clarifications do not allow conformity to be assessed unambiguously; it may declare suitable a tender without substantive deviations (§ 114(2)). Where the procurement is divided into lots, conformity is checked per lot (§ 114(8)). The equivalence rules for specifications, labels and test reports are in the guide on technical specifications.

In the full reverse procedure (täielik pöördmenetlus), the authority may check only the conformity of the tender it intends to declare successful, and must ensure that the contract is not awarded to a tenderer whose tender does not conform (§ 114(1¹)). It is then not required to evaluate suitable tenders only (§ 117(1¹)).

Evaluating and declaring the successful tender

  • By the announced criteria. The authority evaluates the suitable tenders in accordance with the award criteria in the procurement documents, and declares the most economically advantageous tender successful by a reasoned written decision (§ 117(1)).
  • Per lot. Where the procurement is divided into lots, tenders are evaluated and declared successful lot by lot (§ 117(2)).
  • Calculation errors. The authority corrects a calculation error in the value of a tender and notifies the tenderer without delay in a form reproducible in writing. The tenderer has two working days from receiving the notice to say whether it agrees; if it does not, the tender is rejected (§ 117(3)).
  • Abnormally low tenders. A tender whose price or cost seems abnormally low is dealt with under separate rules; see the guide on abnormally low tenders.
  • Environmental, social and labour law. The authority may decide not to award the contract to the successful tenderer if it establishes that the tenderer has not taken account of the environmental, social and labour law rules applicable at the place of performance. It then rejects the successful tender by a written decision, evaluates all the remaining tenders again and declares successful the most economically advantageous of the suitable tenders (§ 117(4)).
  • If the winner drops out. Where the successful tenderer does not sign the contract in time, or for reasons attributable to it does not start performing a contract concluded by acceptance, the authority evaluates the remaining tenders again and declares successful the most economically advantageous of the suitable tenders (§ 119(1)). It need not re-evaluate, and may declare the second-ranked tender successful, where the withdrawal of the successful tender cannot affect the ranking of the others (§ 119(2)).

Notifying the decision

The authority informs the economic operators taking part of the decision to declare a tender successful, within three working days of making it, in a form reproducible in writing (§ 47(1), § 47(1) cl 10). A tenderer whose tender was declared suitable also receives the name of the successful tenderer and the characteristics of the successful tender that gave it an advantage over its own tender (§ 47(4) cl 3). Information whose disclosure would, among other things, breach business secrets or harm competition is withheld (§ 47(5)). The standstill period and the rest of the procedure are in the guide on the open procedure.

Variants (alternatiivsed lahendused)

  • They must be provided for. The procurement documents set out the requirements for variants and how to submit them, including whether the authority allows or requires them only in addition to a solution that meets all the terms of the procurement documents, or separately (§ 77(4) cl 3).
  • Only if allowed in the contract notice. The authority evaluates variants where it has allowed tenders with variants in the contract notice (§ 118(1)).
  • Only conforming variants. It evaluates only the variants declared to meet the requirements set for variants in the procurement documents (§ 118(2)).
  • Supply or service. A variant may not be rejected on the ground that, if the contract were awarded on its terms, it would be a service contract instead of a supply contract, or vice versa (§ 118(3)).

Simple procedure and contesting

In the simple procedure the authority applies § 85 and §§ 114–117 and 119, unless the procurement documents provide otherwise (§ 125(5)). That list does not name § 86 or § 118; the authority sets the procedure in the procurement documents and may follow other provisions of the Act (§ 125(2)). See the guide on the simple procedure.

The award criteria can be contested as part of the procurement documents (§ 185(2) cl 1), and the decision declaring a tender successful can be contested on its own (§ 185(2) cl 7). Time limits and procedure are in the guide on contestation. Questions on selection and exclusion are in the FAQ on exclusion, selection and award. This guide repeats the Act and does not cover case law on award criteria.

Want your procurement documents checked before publication? We will show you how Procurelex Verifika does it.

Request a demo

General information on the Public Procurement Act in force. Not legal advice.